Water Heater Replacement Cost in Hamilton & Niagara

Straight-up pricing — no sales games. Get a new tank or tankless water heater near you with $0 down rent-to-own, or buy it outright. Below are our current 2026 water heater replacement prices for Hamilton, Niagara and the surrounding area.

Whether you're replacing a failed tank, switching from a rental, or upgrading to tankless, there are two simple ways to get a new water heater installed near you:

Rent-to-Own
Low monthly payment, $0 down, a $200 gift card, free replacement of defective parts, and a $0 buyout — the water heater becomes yours.
Buy Outright
Own it from day one. Includes 1-year labour and a 6-year limited parts warranty.

All prices are +HST. Monthly prices are the rent-to-own payment with $0 down. Outright prices are the one-time purchase & standard installation. Your final price depends on current venting, connections and any code upgrades — call 905-679-9420 for a free quote.

Conventional Tank — Atmospheric Vent (AO Smith / John Wood)

Our most popular standard gas water heater. Commercial-grade build.

SizeRent-to-OwnBuy Outright
40 Gallon$29.99/mo$2,278.99
50 Gallon$32.99/mo$2,493.99
60 Gallon$36.99/mo$2,779.99

Electric Tank (AO Smith / John Wood · 60 gal Rheem)

No gas line? An electric water heater is a simple, reliable replacement.

SizeRent-to-OwnBuy Outright
40 Gallon$20.99/mo$1,532.99
50 Gallon$21.99/mo$1,676.99
60 Gallon (Rheem)$23.99/mo$1,819.71

Power Vent Tank (AO Smith / John Wood)

Vents horizontally through a side wall — ideal where a chimney/vent isn't available.

SizeRent-to-OwnBuy Outright
40 Gallon$37.99/mo$2,923.99
50 Gallon$39.99/mo$3,066.99
60 Gallon$42.99/mo$3,281.99

Power Vent Direct Vent Tank (AO Smith / John Wood)

Draws combustion air from outside — a sealed, efficient option for tighter homes.

SizeRent-to-OwnBuy Outright
50 Gallon$44.99/mo$3,325.09
75 Gallon$50.99/mo$3,755.20

Tankless Water Heater (IBC)

Endless hot water and a smaller footprint. We also install Navien and Rinnai tankless — ask for options.

ModelRent-to-OwnBuy Outright
IBC SFT199$62.49/mo$4,300.36

Rent-to-Own vs. Renting from Reliance or Enercare

Renting from a big company feels cheap month-to-month, but you pay forever and get charged a buyout of $1,000–$3,500+ if you ever want to own the unit. With our rent-to-own water heater program the buyout is $0 — every payment moves you toward owning it outright. See the full comparison on our rental buyout page.

Water Heater Cost FAQ

How much does it cost to replace a water heater in Hamilton?

Buying outright runs from $1,532.99 +HST (40-gal electric) up to $3,755.20 +HST (75-gal power-vent direct-vent), with the IBC tankless at $4,300.36 +HST. Rent-to-own starts at $20.99/month +HST with $0 down.

Is there a buyout fee?

No — our rent-to-own water heaters have a $0 buyout. The unit becomes yours, unlike Reliance or Enercare rentals.

Do the prices include installation?

Yes, standard replacement installation is included. Final pricing depends on your venting, connections and any required code upgrades.

Get Your Exact Water Heater Price

Free, no-obligation quote for your home in Hamilton, Niagara & surrounding areas.

Call 905-679-9420