Straight-up pricing — no sales games. Get a new tank or tankless water heater near you with $0 down rent-to-own, or buy it outright. Below are our current 2026 water heater replacement prices for Hamilton, Niagara and the surrounding area.
Whether you're replacing a failed tank, switching from a rental, or upgrading to tankless, there are two simple ways to get a new water heater installed near you:
All prices are +HST. Monthly prices are the rent-to-own payment with $0 down. Outright prices are the one-time purchase & standard installation. Your final price depends on current venting, connections and any code upgrades — call 905-679-9420 for a free quote.
Our most popular standard gas water heater. Commercial-grade build.
| Size | Rent-to-Own | Buy Outright |
|---|---|---|
| 40 Gallon | $29.99/mo | $2,278.99 |
| 50 Gallon | $32.99/mo | $2,493.99 |
| 60 Gallon | $36.99/mo | $2,779.99 |
No gas line? An electric water heater is a simple, reliable replacement.
| Size | Rent-to-Own | Buy Outright |
|---|---|---|
| 40 Gallon | $20.99/mo | $1,532.99 |
| 50 Gallon | $21.99/mo | $1,676.99 |
| 60 Gallon (Rheem) | $23.99/mo | $1,819.71 |
Vents horizontally through a side wall — ideal where a chimney/vent isn't available.
| Size | Rent-to-Own | Buy Outright |
|---|---|---|
| 40 Gallon | $37.99/mo | $2,923.99 |
| 50 Gallon | $39.99/mo | $3,066.99 |
| 60 Gallon | $42.99/mo | $3,281.99 |
Draws combustion air from outside — a sealed, efficient option for tighter homes.
| Size | Rent-to-Own | Buy Outright |
|---|---|---|
| 50 Gallon | $44.99/mo | $3,325.09 |
| 75 Gallon | $50.99/mo | $3,755.20 |
Endless hot water and a smaller footprint. We also install Navien and Rinnai tankless — ask for options.
| Model | Rent-to-Own | Buy Outright |
|---|---|---|
| IBC SFT199 | $62.49/mo | $4,300.36 |
Renting from a big company feels cheap month-to-month, but you pay forever and get charged a buyout of $1,000–$3,500+ if you ever want to own the unit. With our rent-to-own water heater program the buyout is $0 — every payment moves you toward owning it outright. See the full comparison on our rental buyout page.
Buying outright runs from $1,532.99 +HST (40-gal electric) up to $3,755.20 +HST (75-gal power-vent direct-vent), with the IBC tankless at $4,300.36 +HST. Rent-to-own starts at $20.99/month +HST with $0 down.
No — our rent-to-own water heaters have a $0 buyout. The unit becomes yours, unlike Reliance or Enercare rentals.
Yes, standard replacement installation is included. Final pricing depends on your venting, connections and any required code upgrades.
Free, no-obligation quote for your home in Hamilton, Niagara & surrounding areas.
Call 905-679-9420